Catholic in America
Identity politics and tribal thinking has become America's dominant paradigm. Why has the respect for genuine civic friendship and the common good waned? What are the set of moral and spiritual principles needed to reclaim or reimagine what has been lost? How do we use them to make right judgments about our world and to move forward with clarity and joy? The answer is at the heart of the Catholic faith and its social doctrine: rediscovering our common identity as children of the Father, the One who created us for love. Join Jason Adkins, host of Catholic in America, to engage our own time, culture, and political milieu with the Gospel of Jesus Christ and to explore how to live more fully Catholic.
Catholic in America
When Death Becomes Healthcare with Amanda Acthman
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
What happens when death becomes an accepted form of healthcare?
In Canada, euthanasia now accounts for approximately one in twenty deaths. What began as a debate about personal autonomy and end-of-life suffering has become a profound challenge to how society understands medicine, human dignity, and the value of life itself.
On this episode of Catholic in America, Jason Adkins welcomes Amanda Achtman, founder of Dying to Meet You and ethics director at Canadian Physicians for Life, to explore the rapid normalization of euthanasia in Canada and what Americans can learn from its experience.
Drawing on her Jewish family heritage, Catholic faith, Holocaust studies, and the teachings of St. John Paul II, Achtman explains how her life's work became a mission to prevent euthanasia and encourage hope. She reflects on the dangers of dehumanization, the history of Nazi euthanasia programs, and why consent alone cannot settle every question about human dignity.
But this conversation is about much more than legislation.
Through her project Dying to Meet You, Achtman shares the stories of elderly people, individuals living with disabilities, grieving families, and others whose experiences reveal the human consequences of assisted suicide and euthanasia. She explains why loneliness, fear of dependence, and the loss of meaningful activity can shape a person's desire to die, and why genuine accompaniment can offer something profoundly different.
Jason and Amanda also discuss the difference between assisted suicide and euthanasia, the challenges facing healthcare professionals, and the importance of rebuilding a culture that knows how to care for people through suffering, grief, and death.
At the heart of their conversation is a distinctly Christian invitation: we are called not simply to defend life in public policy, but to make sure every person knows that their life remains a gift, that they are loved, and that they have something meaningful to offer until their final breath.
How can Catholics respond to a culture increasingly comfortable with assisted death? By becoming witnesses to hope, one relationship and one story at a time.
Show Links
Dying to Meet You | Amanda Achtman
Personal stories, interviews, and resources exploring suffering, death, human dignity, and hope.
https://dyingtomeetyou.com/
Amanda Achtman | Biography and Speaking Information
https://dyingtomeetyou.com/book-amanda/
Amanda Achtman | YouTube Channel
Watch interviews, personal testimonies, and videos from Dying to Meet You.
https://www.youtube.com/@AmandaAchtman
Canadian Physicians for Life
https://www.physiciansforlife.ca/
Health Canada | Annual Report on Medical Assistance in Dying (2024)
Official Canadian government statistics on medical assistance in dying.
https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/publications/health-system-services/annual-report-medical-assistance-dying-2024.html
Jason Adkins, host of Catholic in America, engages our own time, culture, and political milieu with the Gospel of Jesus Christ and to explore how to live more fully Catholic. With so much to explore, we have guests from a variety of perspectives and faith backgrounds, and conversations do not necessarily constitute endorsements.
Catholic in America is an OSVNews.com podcast partnership. Support Catholic in America by becoming a patron of the show here.
Welcome to Catholic in America, a podcast in partnership with OSB News. I'm Jason Atkins. More and more people are looking at Canada with real concern with the rise of so-called medical aid and dying, what's really euthanasia. It now accounts for one in 20 deaths there and has advanced a real culture of death. It has turned basic questions about health care on their head. Now one doesn't ask whether one would choose assisted suicide, but it really one is asked why wouldn't one choose assisted suicide? It is really normalizing the culture of death in Canada. People wonder why the church should weigh in on public policy questions or why Catholics should be involved in political life, but people forget that policy changes like the legalization of assisted suicide can have enormous pastoral consequences. Just think of the devastation that both legalized marijuana and online sports gambling have wrought in the lives of young people here in the United States. Certainly it's been the case in Canada with regard to the assisted suicide in euthanasia as the church there struggles to respond to the growing pastoral difficulties presented when being killed by a third party is offered as legitimate health care. The light of the gospel can often be seen sometimes most clearly when there is darkness, just like it is through our Lord's wounds that we are healed, and by our weaknesses his glory made manifest. The opportunity to respond to a cultural moment marked by pain and suffering is one way in which people can encounter the divine physician. One Canadian Catholic activist is using this pastoral challenge to be the hands and feet of Jesus and rehumanize conversations around suffering, death, meaning, and hope. She uses stories to help rebuild a true culture of life where people struggling with the issue of euthanasia, and those considering it can see the true human impact of that choice. Amanda Ackman is the founder of Dying to Meet You, an ethics director at Canadian Physicians for Life. She was born and raised in Calgary, Alberta, and holds a master's degree in John Paul II Philosophical Studies from the Catholic University of Lublin in Poland. She also holds a licentiate in Judaic Studies and Jewish Christian relations from the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome. She previously worked on Parliament Hill and Ottawa to prevent the expansion of youth in Asia to persons living with disability or mental illness. I'm glad to have Amanda on the show because I think Catholics in America can benefit from her ministry and deploy its strategies to hold the line against the further expansion of assisted suicide here in the United States, which is currently legal in 13 states and the District of Columbia. Amanda Ackman, welcome to Catholic in America. It's a pleasure to have you on the show.
SPEAKER_02Thank you.
SPEAKER_00You have a great background and educational pedigree and a lot of interesting experiences. You could be described as one of the most interesting women in the world, but um, whether it's Holocaust education and Holocaust studies, uh Judy studying Judaism at the Pontifical Gregorian University, John Paul II studies in Poland, what uh tell us a little bit about your journey as a champion for human dignity and what's led you to where you are today.
SPEAKER_02Sure. Well, uh it's such a gift to look back. I think of how Edith Stein talks about how vocation is better understood in retrospect. And that is certainly how I feel about uh my life and and my trajectory and as I begin to trace the thread of God's providence that led me to this point where my all-in mission right now is preventing euthanasia and encouraging hope. And I was raised in a Jewish Catholic family. So I have Jewish background on both sides, but I'm not a convert. I was raised Catholic from the get-go by my uh parents. And so this was a huge part of my upbringing, both Jewish community and culture, combined with a lifelong practice of the Catholic faith. And I didn't think much of its unusualness because it was simply the life that was uh given to me and in which I was immersed. But over time I came to see this as a particular character uh that has uh been fruitful for my life and my mission. So I had a very, very warm relationship in particular with my Polish Jewish grandfather. And he actually lived with my family at the end of his life in his late 80s and his early 90s. And that was so decisive for me. We really had such a close bond and uh such a deep, deep connection. I think he's a kind of family member with whom I had the most in common. And so it was really a joy to get to know him uh when the occasion arose that he would stay with us. And so that's actually what led me to study the Holocaust and to even move to Poland and to trace my roots to some extent. And then that led me deeper and deeper into my personal sense of uh responsibility to humanize the culture in my home country of Canada.
SPEAKER_00Say a little bit about how Judaism has helped deepen your Catholic faith or an encounter with your Jewish roots. Uh, I have a similar experience in the sense that uh my wife and I met on a trip to the Holy Land. We both studied uh Judaism. I work extensively with uh our Jewish Community Relations Council and feel a deep kinship there. And that certainly helped me on my faith that encounter. But say a little bit about growing up in that environment and how that shaped uh your faith and how you look at your own Catholic faith in light of your Jewish roots.
SPEAKER_02I remember when I was in my last year of high school and a Holocaust survivor spoke at actually a Catholic retreat I was on with my school. And it was at the end of that experience that some uh older students, some university students, who of course high schoolers find extremely cool, explained that it was possible to travel with Holocaust survivors to Germany and Poland. And I bookmarked the link to that page right away, and I knew that at the soonest opportunity I wanted to go on a trip like that. So I went for 10 days on a trip called the March of Remembrance and Hope, Holocaust study trip to Germany and Poland with 60 students and two survivors. And that trip more than any other, and I've traveled extensively and thank goodness had many meaningful travel experiences, but this one comes back to me more than any other. And it was traveling with those survivors, also these uh survivors who generously shared their experiences of trauma, of loss, of losing their entire families, and that they would decide to get on buses with 18 to 30 year olds for 10 days was so moving to me. In a sense, it's deepened in how much it moves me as the time goes on. I feel like I receive that gift, that generosity, that courage from them again and again and anew. Uh, it's also amazing these two survivors are still alive. I went on that trip in 2010 and I have visited them more recently in Toronto. And so it was traveling on that trip when one of our tour guides explained that dehumanization is at the core of genocide. I thought, if dehumanization is at the core of genocide, what is the opposite? What's the antithesis? What does it mean to humanize humanity? And if all of these uh perpetrators so dramatically got the human person wrong, then who can I look to for insight in how to get the human person right? And so it was also receiving that beautiful clarity in John Paul II's uh encyclical, Santissimus Anis, that says the fundamental error of socialism, and we can say of any ideology, is anthropological in nature. It gets the human person wrong. And so that's part of what moved me to return to Poland quite unexpectedly, uh, actually studying John Paul II so close to a place I had been all those years earlier on the Holocaust study trip, so close to a former concentration camp called Majdanic. And in fact, unbeknownst to me at the time, close to where many of my extended family members came from in Poland, or many of them perished if they didn't move to North America, they were killed there. And so I was steeping in this deeply Catholic country, but I was also facing up to these themes of mortality and morality. And it honestly, each time I would spend time contemplating these realities and realize that the only thing that separates me from the fate of those who perished in the gas chambers is uh geography and years. And I started to be filled with the sense of responsibility. Who am I to be here? Why do I get to live? And to feel this as an 18, 20, 25-year-old, and then into my 30s, the sense of overwhelming gift of life, such profound responsibility. And even more recently, I can say I've been completely taken by the idea that uh and the awareness that I am the dream of my ancestors, that I would simply live in freedom and practice my faith in freedom was a dream of my ancestors for me. How could I ever, ever repudiate so much hope that has been staked on me and placed in my future? That is a tremendous awareness that I do not know if every Catholic lives with, but I think that comes from the precariousness of life, from the risk inherent in this existential situation, that, thanks be to God, I find tremendously life-giving uh and a source of actual joy and zeal.
SPEAKER_00Wow, I love the attitude of gratitude there and receiving a legacy and an inheritance and living it to the fullest. Moving. Fantastic. Uh, thank you for that. But tell a little bit, you know, John Paul II being a unique figure in the church's history, but 20th century history too, living through a Polish Catholic leader, lived through World War II, the horrors of that conflict, the Holocaust, uh, and the way in which his own people participated in that in some ways, but were champions against it too. He made his pontificate about better relations against better relations with the Jewish people, memory, remembrance, reconciliation. At the same time, he's the Pope of Evangelium Vitae. And there's a I think there's a thread there. In your mind, what's the what's the thread between the gospel of life and John Paul II's witness in defense of human dignity, especially for the Jewish people?
SPEAKER_02I think it's feeling the stakes and the heights and the depths of the drama of what he called the difficult century. That's how he described it, especially when speaking about St. Maximilian Colby. And so it's this profound sensitivity that is not purely intellectual, but that is lived. If you go to his hometown, as probably you have, Vadovice, and you see the family home museum, and you see that he was uh living with Jewish neighbors and playing with Jewish school children, and and this was a matter of friendship and lived uh experience of recognizing the deep fraternity between Jews and Christians. And then that, but along with also the history of communism and and so many other forms of desecration against the human person, made him awaken so dramatically and made uh God give us this tremendous gift, uh, not only for the church, but uh for the world at large, to receive someone who was truly uh a prophet of hope and an incarnation of these values of the uh irreducible, unique, and unrepeatable dignity of the human person that so awakened people that if you look at footage of people in the crowds with John Paul II, what is in their eyes? How are they being met? It's it's such a sight to behold because you can see that they receive his witness with this awareness of being raised to their proper dignity, of being called higher. And I think that is really what we're all called to do. How can I, in speaking to others, give them that sense that, yes, you're worth it, you're worth my investment, you're worth my time, you're worth my attention, you're worth me staking my life on you. That's what it means to love.
SPEAKER_00I want to explore a little bit more that theme of dehumanization and the way in which the Holocaust, uh keeping this thread going, not just an attack on the Jewish people, principally it was, but of course, others that the Nazis deem lesser races, but also the disabled uh and those with disabilities of various forms. I'm of the view that today, bringing it back to what were our the main topic of our conversation, euthanasia assisted suicide, fundamentally a eugenics bill. Uh that's that's my own view. But say a little bit about the way in which the Holocaust dehumanized all kinds of people, uh, including those with disability, and maybe how that relates back to some of the work you're doing today.
SPEAKER_02Sure. Well, the Action T4 program, the euthanasia program of the Nazis, has been described, and specifically I'm referring to the actual memorial sites in Germany that have uh the description of it as a prelude to the Holocaust. And this is because, first of all, it was citizens of Germany and Austria living with disabilities who were targeted for the euthanasia program, people with disabilities and mental illness, uh, notably the very same uh categories of exclusion that we see in some of the uh euthanasia legislation. And so I think that's that's important to note. There was actually, in fact, uh circumstances where Jews were not allowed in the euthanasia facilities because it was almost seen as too too kind, uh too merciful a death for the Jews. But eventually there were Jews who who did die by the the euthanasia kind of program as well in certain places and uh in some places more than others. And so this history of the Action T4 program of Nazi euthanasia and eugenics is important to bear in mind. And uh in addition to the concentration camps that I've visited, I've also visited four out of six of the former Nazi euthanasia killing centers. And in visiting those places, I do wonder what is the purpose of these memorial sites? Some of them still have the gas chambers that were piloted, in a sense, before they were in concentration camps, they were used in the Action T4 program. And so I would go into these places and I would kind of wonder, what is someone supposed to take away from visiting a former euthanasia site? And these have only become memorial museums relatively recently. Because it's pretty important that people draw the right conclusions, and the facts alone do not always teach morality when visiting these places. So, for example, after visiting one of them, I spoke with some Austrian high schoolers and I said, Do you think there's ever a circumstance where euthanasia is legitimate? And one of the high schoolers immediately said, Yes, if the person consents to it. And so that was the conclusion of this high schooler and all of those who who concurred with this student right away that the only problem was consent. And and that really provoked me to consider what is fundamentally wrong about euthanasia. Is it simply that the person uh in the historical context didn't consent to it? Or is it that a doctor or nurse prematurely uh caused the death of another person, especially on these grounds of exclusion uh due to a kind of criteria? And I started to really ponder this deeply, uh, really for weeks and months after, and it occurred to me that we do live today in a time where we are so keenly aware of how other people can abuse us, mistreat us, dehumanize us. We all know that other people can harm us. So if everyone is so capable of doing this to us, where is our humility to recognize if and when we are doing that to our very selves? And can a person consent to their own dehumanization? And what's going on if that's the case? And can we push back and mount resistance to a person's even willingness to uh desecrate themselves? And is that loving to insist over and against this? So I would say visiting these sites is tremendously uh stirring of ethical reflection. And I will also say that in my search for the value of these sites and the possible takeaways, I would always be looking for an ethical exemplar. I wanted to know was there anyone at all who resisted? And in each place, in all of the euthanasia memorial sites in Germany and Austria, five in Germany and one in Austria, main ones, and in Yad Vashem, the Holocaust Museum in Israel and Jerusalem, the singular figure of resistance, pretty much, who is extolled, is Bishop Clemens von Gallen, a bishop known as the Lion of Munster, the Lion who roared against the Nazis, a bishop who had the courage to denounce the Nazi euthanasia program in three of his homilies during the war. And so, whatever uh clergy might fear today, let that be uh a dramatic uh appeal to conscience and to responsibility. And so I'm very taken by uh blessed Clemens von Gallen and his witness, and I've also traveled to Munster to trace his steps and to even pray at his tomb as I seek to be a voice of resistance, however small but however uh constant as I can muster uh in favor of defending life.
SPEAKER_00We could go on and on about how we got to a point where consent became the standard of the good. Uh, that we live in a world where people's mental architecture and their moral architecture is fundamentally libertarian, as you've described. How successful have you been, however, in this argument that we cannot consent to our own dehumanization? I think that is super powerful and really lays bare what it's at what's at stake, because you can think of a lot of ways in which people can't consent to their own dehumanization that most people would agree with. But in this context, it seems, the polls often show in various places that just at a very basic gut level, people want to be to control how they die and have the option to coerce a medical professional into helping them do that. So, how much traction have you gotten with the argument that we can't consent to our own dehumanization?
SPEAKER_02It takes a very demanding level of relational work to expose that that seeming consent to dehumanization is actually an expression of dejection and woundedness, and usually arises from a place of self-protection and not from a place of ideals. So, to give an example and make that really concrete, I was traveling to Vancouver Island, which is really the euthanasia capital of the world, and one of the uh community members arranged a whole series of one-to-ones for me with different community members across the board. And in fact, the first woman who I was scheduled to meet with, to my amazement, is a woman who, as we sat down to coffee, began the conversation saying, I know we're gonna disagree. I want made medical aid in dying as soon as this or that happens, as soon as I have this or that condition uh befall me, and you're not gonna change my mind. What do you know, by the way? You're you're young, you seem healthy, and and she went on and on and on about why she thinks she wants euthanasia in the future for some uh kind of as yet unseen reason. And I listened and I listened. And even though I had just met her and so naturally knew not very much about her, I had the audacity to say to her, What you're telling me doesn't correspond to your heart. And she had nothing to say because it was true. And I said, You probably have reasons to self-protect and to mount the defense. And you probably doubt whether someone will be with you in the situations you describe. But you deserve better. And I hope, I hope that you never ever go through with this. And those are powerful conversations when uh in other circumstances I've been told by such persons, usually uh an elderly person, but nobody has ever told me that. So here I am as as a stranger or as a neighbor or as a friend, a new friend, simply saying, I hope you never ever go through with it. And that itself is kind of like an argument, though it doesn't really seem like one. But it's it's staking my very self in favor of the person, which is more than any syllogism can do. And it's staking my very hope on that person when I describe how emboldened I am at the thought that I'm the dream of my ancestors who hoped that I would flourish. I, because of what I've received, desire so deeply to give that emboldening gusto to a person who may think that their life is over or their value has expired. But in fact, I insist, no, it is culminating. It's coming to a crescendo. Don't miss it.
SPEAKER_00So incredibly powerful. And you you see that in a lot of different contexts where what people are trying to do is create some agency over their life and control exercise control when they've lost it in so many contexts, when they're wounded, hurting. I've seen the same thing, uh, but you've just really presented it to us in a powerful, humanized, personalized, dramatized, and humanized, as we say, which leads me to the dying to meet you and your quest as a champion of human dignity to speak into this moment in Canada, which we south of the border continue to look at aghast as to what's going on there. How did you, how did you dying to meet you? Tell us about it, how you got involved in this issue of assisted suicide, medical aid, and dying euthanasia, and what you're trying to achieve.
SPEAKER_02I've been following the issue really since before legalization, because it was in those years that my grandfather was still alive before it had been legalized. And and I realized that the government was talking about euthanasia for people whose deaths are reasonably foreseeable. And so I had my grandfather in his 90s uh so close to me. I thought, wait a minute, that means people like him. And he's had good days and bad days. And I've certainly uh heard him on those uh tough days where I wouldn't have wanted that worst day to be his last. Um, so so it kind of heightened my uh ethical sensitivity in a very uh natural way. And then over the years, Canada did legalize euthanasia uh in 2016, and uh I was actually studying St. Augustine in Lublin, and we were reading on the free choice of the will, and Augustine discusses suicide, and I was quite taken by his treatment of it so early on there. And he talks about how those who uh say they don't want to live or that they desire to die don't actually want not to exist, but they actually desire goods. And I became so curious if that were true that I started to measure it against the Supreme Court cases in Canada, mostly involving women with ALS who were advocating to have a doctor and their life. And in those court cases, it became very apparent that indeed uh these these women with ALS did desire goods like comfort, dignity, dignity, privacy, autonomy, control, goods of life, not goods that you secure by uh no longer existing. And so that already started to provoke me to think, well, people deserve better. They deserve to be oriented toward the goods they seek. And even if those goods can't be fulfilled, it's very different to be ordered toward them always, than to have the capacity to even order yourself to them extinguished. I think of this woman I interviewed very recently, and uh she's uh a beautiful witness. I asked her, I said, the main reason Canadians are seeking euthanasia is not actually because of pain or the fever of pain, it's actually because of a loss of meaningful activities and inability to engage in meaningful activities, as the government data puts it. And so I asked this woman who is really uh on the cusp of dying naturally, and I said to her, uh, what can a person never lose? And she said, Well, we can never lose the fact that everything is meaningful, she said, even if I can't do it. And I thought, ha, she understands that the world doesn't cease to exist. It's not that all is obliterated simply when we cease to be a part of it. And yet that takes a lot of humility. That takes a lot of humility to say that the world is still good and everything is so beautiful, not everything, but that there is so much uh beauty and goodness, and that it really will kind of go on after me, and it was here before me, and and that just requires such a posture of humility that cannot be uh mustered in final moments uh without a kind of practice of this continual awareness um and reminder that that led her to that point that everything is meaningful even if I can't do it. And I just saw that disposition as as so luminous and uh attractive, and I want to be like her and I want to die like her, uh, I think it's it's really exemplary. So some years later, after moving back from Poland, I started working with a member of parliament. And what the government was doing during the COVID years was expanding euthanasia on the basis of disability and mental illness. And the reason for that is because once euthanasia or assisted suicide is legalized, it has to be expanded on the basis of equality. It must be, because if it's seen as a reasonable and compassionate means to end suffering, why would you exclude anyone from that who is suffering? It makes no sense. If this is a reasonable way to tackle suffering, why would we withhold that from children? Shouldn't children have the most compassion and receive the most uh mercy? So why would we, as it just becomes completely contradictory, but that's because of the confusion about the good. At this point, I also want to make a distinction between euthanasia and assisted suicide, which we tend to use interchangeably, but which have a technical distinction. In Canada, uh the term MAID, medical aid in dying, was uh employed to be an umbrella term encompassing both euthanasia on the one hand and assisted suicide on the other. The difference being with assisted suicide, which is the only uh one that's uh in exists in the U US, the patient is required to self-administer, which is a massive deterrent, thankfully. Still not good, but I mean it's a deterrent. With euthanasia, the doctor or nurse practitioner directly administers a lethal injection, ending the patient's life usually in about 10 to 15 minutes. And so in Canada, there's the option. And in the first years, there were a handful of people who self-administered. But I find it extremely notable that for the last year, for which we have federal data, 2024, 100% of the 16,499 Canadians who died by MAID were directly euthanized by a doctor or nurse. Not a single one self-administered. So if you're wondering in America what's up with Canada, why are the numbers so much higher than here? That's why. And if you think that that couldn't happen in the US, my warning to Americans is you are one lawsuit away. Because once you have an assisted suicide regime, all it takes is one person claiming that it's against their equality rights, because for, for example, due to a disability, it's impossible to self-administer to take a life. And then the option becomes available to have a doctor or nurse do it instead. And you have the mutual outsourcing of responsibility where a doctor says, I'm simply fulfilling the patient's wishes, and the patient says, I'm simply undergoing this uh legal medical option. And that's what makes it so much more ubiquitous and widespread. Now, the other thing that many uh Americans, I think, struggle to see in the popularity of euthanasia in Canada and in how it has genuinely become uh so compelling that seniors will tell me they they basically have to explain why they wouldn't schedule their death. That's the point we're at now. Now, where one in 20 deaths is uh caused by a doctor or nurse, usually in a private home, more so than hospitals. And so the idea of having a doctor or nurse come to your private residence or to a home-like setting and end life in a very controlled way has become seductive for several reasons. And I think one of those reasons is the sham form of accompaniment, but accompaniment nonetheless of the provider, so-called, of the euthanasia. Now, this is devastating, but it demonstrates again the lowering of standards and the deflated expectations of the elderly that anyone will be with them. And so by scheduling a euthanasia death, a person guarantees a vigil of sorts. People gather around at the appointed hour, and it's convenient, it's less uh cumbersome for people's schedules, and so not only for the doctor or nurse, but for, for example, family and friends who might gather around. Of course, Catholics are uh told that it's inappropriate and and prohibited really to be present at a euthanasia death. But that's what's going on, is that there's this sense of um guaranteeing the vigil by scheduling the death.
SPEAKER_00What's amazing uh is the way in which assisted suicide, and you may you make the helpful distinction between assisted suicide and euthanasia, the third party doing it to you. The legislation, as you noted here in the United States, uh basically sends people home with a vial of pills or some powder to ingest on their own. And so, of course, the the question becomes if that's what it is, and a lot of people think it's euthanasia, but it's really this assisted suicide ingesting of powder. Gets back to my point from earlier. Then what's the why is how is this not a eugenics bill at the end of the day? Because you could easily do that with a bottle of Tylenol, I hate to say it, but what do we need to do institutionalize this for? And it's precisely because I think Derek Humphreys, founder of Compassion and Choices, the Hemlock Society, was fundamentally a eugenicist. But it's a it's amazing to listen to you talk about the way in which assisted suicide has morphed into euthanasia and the way in which people are looking for this accompaniment at death.
SPEAKER_02Since you mentioned Derek Humphrey, I think it's it's notable that he actually, for all his promotion of assisted suicide throughout his life, actually died naturally in Oregon of all places. And I think that's a really striking thing to consider. How many of those who are involved in euthanasia and assisted suicide actually don't choose it for themselves? And I think part of what's at play there is this kind of technocratic mastery over life. And I think this is why it's especially seductive for doctors and nurses to consider euthanasia and assisted suicide, because it is so antagonizing of their identity as healers and as interveners in kind of human health, that when uh they themselves become a patient, it is so destabilizing and disorienting uh of their identity. So that's something really to attend to because I do notice that um many, many times it is uh doctors and nurses who who think that this is uh a reasonable thing to do. But of course, there are also many, many doctors and nurses who are completely opposed, who would never be involved in it, who find it completely contradictory to the Hippocratic tradition of medicine and to their own sense of of what they're called to do.
SPEAKER_00So let's talk about dying to meet you and the specific purpose of that project. We talk about personalizing, dramatizing, and humanizing the stories uh around this issue. Say a little bit about what you hope to achieve by getting people on film, having those conversations, and what do you hope to achieve long term?
SPEAKER_02Yes, it is time to come back to that dying to meet you theme. So thank you for bringing me back. There's so many important aspects about euthanasia and assistant suicide itself.
SPEAKER_00But I was I love all the tangents. It's great.
SPEAKER_02While I was working in that office of a member of parliament, we put out a call for stories and we said, we need your stories to explain how the expansion of euthanasia on the basis of disability and mental illness would affect you and your loved ones. And hundreds of stories poured in. And there I was in the midst of the pandemic, pouring through a binder of hundreds of personal stories. And it felt like this political office where I was a staffer became like a suicide prevention center. And I felt that it was extremely important to give everyone an appropriate, thoughtful response to their generous sharing of their story. We started uh with permission, kind of anonymizing the stories and using them in uh politicians' speeches in the House of Commons. And uh some of the stories uh also became uh short film interviews that were released under the politician's account. And I realized that that had tremendous power to transcend the political spectrum and to tell a really human story. And so as I realized that we were outnumbered in in parliament and the law was going to pass, how do I work with this kind of Christian detachment about the result, knowing that it's going to result in thousands and thousands more people dying every year by euthanasia was extremely tormenting and agonizing. So I thought about responsibility and I thought about how in Canada, in my uh estimation, we don't just have a culture of death. Of course, I know what John Paul II meant by that, but we have death with no culture. We're losing the cultural tenor around death and dying, like all these uh customs and a sense of what to do and how to live these realities properly. So I made a New Year's resolution on January 1st, 2021, to blog about death every single day for one year, which I did. And uh that was the blog was called Dying to Meet You. And it was simply my own catharsis to contend with losing legislatively, and feeling that I had to bring some degree of cultural renewal around these themes of suffering, death, meaning, and hope, if only in my own heart. Because if I didn't bring them first to my own heart, I couldn't expect to see anything improve in the society around me. And so that's that's what I did. And at first I thought, what was I thinking on day three, on day seven, and four view counts, seven view counts. It was it was very small, but eventually there were uh thousands and thousands of unique visitors to the site, and more than just reading it, people were actually uh changing their lives because of it. One of my friends fully moved from teaching to hospice work because of reading the blog. Another friend did a birthday fundraiser. He and his twin brother raised money for uh a foundation that grants uh good wishes to dying patients to kind of help fulfill uh simple kind of joys at end of life. And that was a beautiful cause. Or I started to learn a lot more about the cemeteries of different uh minorities across Canada and burial rituals, and it was it was so life-giving. Honestly, spending a year writing about death, not writing about euthanasia, but writing about simply death from a cultural standpoint was so energizing. It became the highlight of my day. It became an excuse to have meaningful, tender conversations with people that I would not have had otherwise, because people started to say, Oh, you have the death blog. And they would send me an article and I found that quite touching, or people would come into the office on Parliament Hill, uh, people I didn't even know, some interns or other staffers, and they'd say, Hey, can I tell you my story? And if you like, you could write about it. And that was extraordinary. And I would say a few years later, after going to Rome as my uh downtime from the political frenzy, I studied the resurrection of the dead for two years as my reprieve. And then I moved back to Canada with this call to kind of revive Dying to Meet You and uh let it become this kind of full, fuller scale cultural project through video testimony, through interviews, through speaking and workshops, and really like uh just kind of seeing how it unfolds quite organically. And it's kind of all the best of the past several years. And I would say one of the most incredible things I've I've noticed is that people do not hesitate to share their stories. Like, I don't think I've ever had a time where I had kind of hoped to interview someone on camera and they didn't want to be. Like, maybe it takes time, maybe it's going to be really patient, maybe they absolutely need to see the final cut before it's made public and things like that. But the the willingness of people to share their story, the catharsis that it brings to them as well, it's tremendous. And so I remember even from the blog days of sometimes calling people and saying, Hey, be late at night in my time zone. And I'd call someone uh in the West and I'd say, could you tell me about a death in your family? And immediately people always wanted to share. So I would just really put that forward as encouragement for how we can humanize the culture, have casual conversations every single day about these topics because it's extremely um helpful to be a shelter for the wounds of others. I think about this a lot as I reflect on the Anima Christi, where the line is, in your wounds hide me. And I found that so curious. Like, how is a wound a place to hide that does not seem uh like like a comfortable place to go? But if part of being in God's image and part of following Christ is is being a shelter for the wounds of others, then where do we do that? But in our very own woundedness. And there's this beautiful kind of reciprocity when we we bear our our mutual vulnerability. And I think helping people to see that as much as we might want to spurn these uh experiences of vulnerability or weakness, if you ask yourself, when have you experienced the greatest intimacy and communion? When have you put your phone away? When have you had those tender moments of connection that you would not have wanted to miss? A lot of times they are moments of suffering, uh of dying, of grieving. And I think we just have to rehabilitate that those are the moments that break open our hearts, that soften our hearts, and to not be so, so afraid of them. And Christians definitely are at the forefront of this evangelization because we have confidence that vulnerability and weakness, rather than becoming a source of alienation, are God's strategy for connection. That he builds his identification with us through becoming weak. And and so we do we really don't want to repudiate our own weakness lest we undermine our attunement with God's strategy in the incarnation.
SPEAKER_00It's as though Christ invites us into sharing our wounds and hiding them in his wounds, and it's he was glorified by his wounds. When you become like him. And conform yourself like Saint Francis did, he gives you his wounds. But those woundedness, that woundedness is the way in which he helps make us saints. And so a beautiful way of I think you've stated it so beautifully and movingly. Thank you for that. What have been the fruits of dying to meet you that you've seen around you?
SPEAKER_02Oh, well, there's there's so many. And I would say, like, one of the biggest joys is basically finding people who are to use Pope Francis phrase on the periphery and bringing them from the periphery and giving them a platform. So I think especially of the elderly or of persons living with dis disabilities or spending a long time in hospital, um, living in their home without many visitors, things like this. And um I would tell you the story of one woman I met named Miriam, also on Vancouver Island, and I was giving a talk at a parish, and I was showing a video actually of my friend Benjamin. Benjamin sadly lost both of his grandmothers to euthanasia within two months of each other. And so after showing that video, usually by sharing a story, it invites people to then share their stories. And so after the event was over and people were heading home, Miriam told me uh that she was offered euthanasia practically upon arrival to a Canadian hospital. She says that her daughter called the ambulance when she heard her mother screaming in pain such that she never experienced before. And she got an ambulance to the hospital and yeah, was in this excruciating pain. The doctor who came over to see her sees this 84-year-old woman in agony and says, We would like to offer you maid. Because her suffering was clearly intolerable. She was very elderly, and and so um Miriam told me, I had just arrived. I didn't even know what was wrong with me. I hadn't had an x-ray. Maid was the furthest thing from my farthest thing from my mind. And then it took her a month to recover from what was a serious back issue. She says she recuperated nicely enough and within the year was traveling to Mexico, Cuba, and Guatemala. And when she told me that story, I thought, well, that's nuts, and you're awesome. And would you be willing to tell that story on camera? And I would say that I definitely have a preferential uh kind of uh just a preference for for retired people because they're so free. They're so free and uninhibited to kind of share their stories and to be courageous. Uh, we could all learn a lot from the courage of retired people that kind of comes once people have um yeah, reached that that point. So she said, yeah, for sure, I'm happy to share the story. So I I recorded a clip on my phone of her telling that story and uh posted it on a kind of politically newsy day when my uh home province of Alberta was introducing uh a bill to prevent euthanasia from being raised unprompted, in fact. And I got a few hundred thousand views, and people began wanting to talk to Miriam and uh to hear her story from her directly, which is how it should be. And so uh she started to field all these media requests, and uh she was on the front page of Canada's National Post. She was in People magazine, the Daily Mail, the New York Post. Uh, she was asked by the free press to write a personal essay, um, first-person story of what happened. And she had a great joy doing that. And uh people from all across the country, her former students, she was a piano teacher, uh, started contacting her. And uh her friends thought it was kind of neat that she was uh becoming such an advocate uh and being uh yeah, interviewed and I showed her how to do Zoom interviews and fix her lighting and everything. Uh it was it was just so much fun to bring her story to the forefront. And it's kind of like if not for this intergenerational solidarity, that wouldn't have happened. She was never gonna make a video and share it with the world without a young person coming alongside and seeing the value to that. And so I think very often of how Pope Francis said that the alliance between old and young will save the human family. I think that's a beautiful recipe for pro-life work in our century, this alliance between old and young. And so I remember writing to Miriam's daughter, Jordan, and saying, So, what does Miriam think of of all of this? And and Jordan said, Well, I had to explain to her what Twitter is, but she gets it now. And it's like, this is this is amazing. And so I could tell a story like that for every every single uh vignette, video vignette that I've produced. And usually, even before the video becomes public, I already am saying it would have been enough if we just recorded this video together and had this conversation in a living room or in this hospital room, it would have been enough. And I have such profound existential satisfaction at coming alongside and dignifying people's stories with a young camera crew that says, by our presence, your story is really worth it. And we came for you. And in each occasion, it's exceptionally moving that for however well I know the person in advance, and I always know them, obviously, to some extent, before we're we're filming a full interview together. In every moment uh of doing that, there has been a moment where the person, the interviewee, shares something they've never shared before, where they go deeper. And uh probably the most uh kind of intense example of that is when I was interviewing a woman named Christine. This is one of my first vignettes, and uh, this woman in her late 80s who always discouraged her own children from ever getting tattoos in their life. But when Canada legalized euthanasia, Christine decided to get a tattoo right here that says, Don't euthanize me. And so I did an interview with her and had befriended her. We had had several visits together, but it was only when the cameras were rolling, it was only when the film crew was there, um, that when I asked her, How do you know for sure that you never want euthanasia? She opened up about having attempted suicide earlier in her life and really feeling the value of life. And I thought, how profound that like now she's not just this kind of pious uh church lady moralizing, but no, she's someone who's really been on the brink and who is bearing her vulnerability for the life of the world. And just getting to be a custodian of people's stories to steward them into the world with the trust that is uh necessary and the reverence that is deserved is so great. There's nothing I would rather do, and I'm I'm so happy if my life is for this.
SPEAKER_00Wow. I love this conversation. Thank you. Thank you so much. You I don't I want to go back to something you said though, and I think people will really feel challenged by it, which is you know, you suggested that we start having these humanizing conversations with people, and I think that's the big barrier is people stepping out of their comfort zones and doing that and going there. How do you give us some tips for just how do we do that? How do we do that effectively? Step out of that comfort zone, invite the conversation, um, get over the awkward as there is, you know, live in the awkward. How do we do that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, it can be really simple to start. For example, if you attend a funeral of someone, tell someone I was at a funeral the other day, and this is what it was like. Talk about it. A lot of times people go to these events and then they don't share with anyone that they've gone. And I think just, oh, you were at a funeral. Interesting. I was at a funeral two months ago for this person. Suddenly you have this connection because everyone's been at a funeral, or hopefully. Uh, and so, or even sharing, yeah, just like I went and I visited this person in the hospital who just had this surgery, and it's like, oh, uh, I know someone who had that same surgery. Like, it becomes a basis for communion so quickly because of the shared vulnerability of the human condition. But everyone holds back if there isn't that opening, because where does it seem appropriate? Otherwise, it seems out of place and it seems kind of awkward. But you see that if you initiate any kind of opening like that, usually people take to it because it's like, oh, now I can be real. Now I can kind of let down my guard and share that I too have been touched by suffering and I too want to uh let like let it be known that that I'm in this too. So yeah, I'm just I'm really struck by how much uh freedom and ease there is when we create opportunities to do this. Uh, the parish can be a really great context for that. Seniors' ministries, I see, are are beginning to emerge. And I think that's a very hopeful uh aspect for the church. We have so much youth ministry. How about more seniors ministry? Uh, and definitely at the leadership of seniors themselves. I will say that um for all of the uh seniors in particular who would say, Why doesn't this exist for me? Well, it's up to us to encourage that leadership among them. And I think of this one woman uh from my hometown who, after her husband died, she went to her parish priest and said, Why is there no ministry for widows like me? This is so unacceptable. I'm in this grief. I have no one, I don't have anyone who gets it. And she and the the priest just listened for a moment and then said, You are hereby appointed the founder of the parish widows and widowers ministry. And for the past more than 10 years, she's been leading monthly potlucks for widows and widowers. And the ministry is exquisite. I went once and I was blown away. Everyone goes around and introduces themselves and says, How long since they lost their spouse and they have a potluck and they acknowledge birthdays and anniversaries and they do fundraisers for the community, and it was extraordinary. And it was like, whoa, if that is what happens when you become a widow or widower, that you go to a meeting like that, maybe it's less fearful. And I really take note of something like that because when I read through what I call the euthanasia obituaries, because many obituaries do mention now that a person has died by maid, it's so often that I can tell by the obituary itself that the person lost their spouse within the past year. And that's part of the motivation. Of course, they have some qualifying, eligible condition. They're not saying to their physician that I'm dying of grief and so I'm opting for maid. But have some curiosity. If I, as a reader of a newspaper obituary, can put this together, we're definitely not doing enough for people in in uh in grief. So uh there's just so many opportunities for uh spiritual and cultural entrepreneurship. And that's one of my big passions when I speak to audiences, mostly of seniors, and I basically tell them the same thing that I've been told my whole life as a young person. You have a mission, you're responsible, you can do great things, the community is counting on you. All we have to do is revive this motivational language and exhortation to mission to everyone in every season of life, because we know that a person never ceases to have the capacity to make a gift of themselves ever. A person never, ever, ever, ever, as long as they have breath, loses the capacity to make a gift of themselves. And so that is the meaningful activity that cannot be lost no matter what.
SPEAKER_00I was hoping you maybe could say a little bit more about this idea of Christian detachment, because I think uh the level of detachment that you were able to cultivate when Canada went the wrong way on this issue from a policy standpoint opened the door for you to do something really pastorally and evangelically creative with dying to meet you. So help us for those of us in the states who see our states going in the wrong direction on so many issues and and lamenting, really weeping over our places, our homes, uh, and the way in which our brothers and sisters are choosing uh not goods but evils in many ways. But then rather than running from that, uh building Babylon's good, so to speak, um, and planting seeds of renewal, help us understand how you've been able to cultivate that detachment and turn the challenges in the public and political culture into something evangelically creative.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh that's a beautiful question. Thank you. I would say part of it comes from having a sense of history. I spend a lot of time steeping in the history of both Nazism and communism and tracing the stories of saints, heroes, and martyrs uh all throughout Europe in particular. And so part of it is a kind of, yeah, things are bad here, but perspective. And I have the freedom to to speak and to write. And like for a moment, it's really important to count the blessings that we do have in our societies that for all the crises still were the dream of those who came before us and still were secured and hard fought for. And so we really ought to uh cherish that and and not act as if the world is all against us. Like, no. Um, and even if we were antagonized to the nth degree, we wouldn't lose the capacity to be uh kind of just a flicker in the darkness and to be that that lone voice of resistance or steadfastness. And um, given that those are the people who I admire so much, who I travel to to the ends of the earth to to pray at their tombs or to be at sites connected to to their lives and devotion, it's just like okay, like you don't have to be, you don't have to have deliverables that are uh magnificent, you just have to be faithful, like Mother Teresa said. Uh, and then a lot of uh the fruitfulness is up to God and and others. I will also say that I I haven't always had this uh clear disposition and uh always uh positive outlook. For example, when um I I read a story about a man named Christopher, and he shared it on his Substack about his father's euthanasia death. Uh very sad story of how his father was was euthanized. And um I I had planned to meet Christopher in person. He's now living abroad, and uh his his family, his father was killed in Canada, but he's he's now living in in the UK. And I planned to meet him at a coffee shop and just to hear his story uh face to face. And as I was walking to the coffee shop, I thought about potentially asking if I could interview him on camera to share his story. But I thought to myself, my mission is preventing euthanasia and encouraging hope. And his story of his father's death is just tragic. Like there's no there's no hopeful uplift to it. And so I I don't think I'd even propose propose this to him anymore. And I get to the coffee shop, take a seat, and um he walks in some minutes later. As soon as I saw his face, it was like the Holy Spirit grabbed me by the shoulders and said, Like, you will not leave this man until you find a reason for his hope with him. And I was really shocked because I didn't know in that moment where that was gonna come from or what that was gonna look like. But it was true that in looking at him, in receiving his story face to face, I knew he couldn't be left in despair for sure. And so I waited, I waited to the end of him sharing his testimony for whatever words God would give me. And what I was able to say to him, really as the result of just receiving his story, is I said, Christopher, if your father's life and death will be more fruitful than he knew how to make it because of the generosity of your testimony and how you're bearing witness to the truth right now. I was stunned when I said it, because as I said, I I did not have that before. It only came from the face, as uh philosopher Emmanuel Levinos says, like the face is what's ethical in nature. And so step by step, um it it came to be that we actually did produce a video uh a vignette titled Not Made for This about his story. And it has this caricature of of hope, where I I conclude by asking him, what gives you the strength to share your story? And he says, sometimes you just have to you have to speak, and maybe this is gonna be a help to others, and so that basis for transcendence and I would just say that's the that's a massive consolation that even in the face of so much loss and misuse of human freedom, the way in which coming alongside others and and living this out with as much integrity as we can, it's really tremendous. I wouldn't I wouldn't trade that for anything. And so also in in parishes, sometimes people come up to me in tears and they're like, I'm being cut out of the family because this relative is planning to die by maid, and I haven't even said anything against it. They just know that that I'm a Catholic, and so that I disagree, and and I just try and really encourage people that like even if a person misuses their freedom and opts for maid, let it be known that you resisted and that you didn't want this for them. Because how good would that be if a person's dying thought in their mind going to you is, but this person didn't want it. This person loved me well in the world until the end. And so that is a secure basis for our hope that we can love those who are in the world well after the pattern of Christ to the end, whether they misuse their freedom or not, and that our loving resistance, that mounting resistance to a form of suicidal ideation is always an act of love. And that act of love is bigger than death.
SPEAKER_00I hate to end this conversation because my heart is burning uh with the gospel because of your powerful words. So thank you. We will put on our show page links to your fine work and help people get better acquainted with you and uh dying to meet you. How can we, Catholics in America who listen to this show, support you? And do you have any last words for our listeners about living the gospel of life uh in the midst of this both suffering and the political context of this issue of euthanasia?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, thanks for having me for this conversation. It's really uh a gift to share it with you. And yeah, check out dyingtomeetyou.com for all the vignettes and lots of other commentary around this. There's also a great QA section compiled by all different experts on many different facets of these questions, people with disabilities, uh, physicians, lawyers. So that's that's quite interesting. And um yeah, just have have those meaningful conversations every day. Share stories. If you like, you can reach out through the website to share stories and um yeah, keep making a gift of yourself until your last breath. I guess the very last thing I would say is even if you don't have assisted suicide in your state, or even if you don't know anyone who's personally affected by this issue directly, I guarantee you that all of the reasons leading people to request euthanasia already exist and are just beneath the surface and are already in our human hearts. And so it's already time to attend to those fears of being a burden, to those losses uh of meaning, to the fear of losing dignity or autonomy or independence. All of that already is at stake and at issue, and we know it. And so, how are you going to attend to it right now, right here, before it becomes even more costly?
SPEAKER_00Amen. The polling, even in what we call red states, here is uh oftentimes very strongly supportive of this issue, and people are surprised by that. So it's coming to a state and a jurisdiction near you, and we need powerful, faithful witnesses to stand up in a compelling, compassionate, and evangelical way. Like you, Amanda Ackman. Thank you for joining us on Catholic in America, sharing your faith, your journey, and your wisdom as we continue to build a culture of life. God bless you. Know of our prayers for your work.
SPEAKER_02Thanks, Jason.
SPEAKER_00Amanda's evangelical entrepreneurialism is truly inspiring and a testament to the power of someone who saw a real problem and was moved by the Holy Spirit to find a solution through the eyes of Christ. Here in Minnesota, we have been successfully working to stop the legalization of assisted suicide for the last 12 years. Yet I gained much insight from this conversation I can take back to our advocacy efforts. But I also appreciated Amanda's perspective about what it means to see and address the pain of those who are seeking to be euthanized and those who want to make it possible for others to do so as well. It's often not about pain. Sometimes it's really about control. Some want that control because they cannot bear to be dependent on others. And some seek assisted suicide because it is the only thing they can control in a difficult healthcare context. But as we discussed, one cannot consent to one's dehumanization. The dehumanization of a growing class of peoples will be the result of the expansion of so-called medical aid in dying. We will replay the horrors of prior ages and undermine the dignity of those with depression and mental illness, the chronically ill, and those with disability. Assisted suicide and youth in Asia also upend the practice of medicine, foster distrust between doctors and patients, and convert the right to die into a duty to die. No matter what the state of our laws, however, our mission remains the same. The hard work of accompanying people in love, letting them know that they are seen and cared for, and that their life matters and it is good, no matter their weakness. That is our calling in this society today. Again, no matter what the laws may present us. Thankfully, creative ministries such as Dying to Meet You are showing us the way to meet this cultural moment and pastoral crisis. Thanks again for listening to this episode of Catholic in America. I hope you have found it as inspiring and edifying and educational as I have. I appreciate your generosity in taking time out to listen to this show to be formed informed so that together we can transform our culture as disciples and Catholics in this United States of America. Thanks again for listening. God bless you and your family, and until next time on Catholic in America, I wish you all the best. I'm Jason Atkins. Take care, pray for me, and I'll pray for you.
SPEAKER_01This OSV podcast production is in partnership with OSV News. Visit OsVnews.com to learn more.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.